DECLARATION OF COMILLA–FINNRAGE-UBINIG CONFERENCE ON HEALTH
DECLARATION OF COMILLA–FINNRAGE-UBINIG CONFERENCE ON HEALTH
Newsletter Dec 1989
1. We, the women from Australia, Austria, Bangladesh, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, Egypt, Fiji, France, Federal Republic of Germany, Hong Kong, Holland, India, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, Mauritius, Norway, Pakistan. Peru, Philippines, Sri Lanka, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, U.K., Uganda, U.S.A., Zambia have met in Comilla, Bangladesh, to share our concern about reproductive and genetic engineering and women's reproductive health. We feel an urgent need to halt the political decisions which are leading to the rapid development and increasing application of these technologies.
2. Initial experiences with reproductive and genetic engineering all over the world show that these technologies are aggravating the deteriorating position of women in society and intensifying the existing differences among people in terms of race, class, caste, sex and religion. These technologies also contribute to the further destabilizing of the already critical ecological situation.
3. Genetic and reproductive engineering are part of an ideology of eugenics which we oppose. In this ideology human beings are viewed as inherently inferior or superior. This leads to degradation, discrimination and elimination of oppressed groups, be they women, disabled people of certain colors, races, religions, class, or caste. Similarly traits of animals and plants are arbitrarily valued as being desirable or undesirable and become subject to genetic manipulation.
4. Eugenics justifies the political strategy used by those in power to divide and rule.
5. Women from the participating countries described how eugenic ideology and racism are the basis of population control policies. We resist population control policies and methods. They hide the true roots of poverty as exploitation by the rich. They reduce women to their reproductive organs. We object to women being used as experimental subjects by science, industry and government.
6. Genetic and reproductive engineering as well as population control are introduced and promoted on the grounds that they solve problems such as hunger, disease and pollution. In reality, however, they divert attention from the real causes and are incapable of solving these problems. Nor do they reflect women's demands and needs.
7. Genetic and reproductive engineering claim to offer unlimited control over all life forms, but tinkering with genetic codes opens up a truly uncontrollable situation of "runaway designer genes" and unintended consequences. These changes will be particularly hazardous because a chain reaction will be set in motion which cannot be traced back to its origins. The effects produced cannot be countered. They will be irreversible.
8. In our increasingly materialistic and consumer oriented world, genetic engineering is promising unlimited diversity. But to live in a man-made patriarchal world where everything has been tampered with will be to live with the ultimate limitation. Our present finite world of resources offers a richer diversity than that promised by genetic engineering with its selective, eugenic, and patriarchal philosophy.
9. Genetic and reproductive engineering are a product of the development of science which started off by viewing the whole world as a machine. Just as a machine can be broken down into its components, analysed and put back, living beings are seen as consisting of components which can he viewed in isolation.
Aspects of nature which cannot be measured or quantified are seen as subjective and of no value and therefore neglected. In their ignorance or disregard of the complex interrelationships in life, scientists collaborate with industry and big capital and believe they have finally acquired the power to create and reconstruct pIants, animals, other forms of life and, possibly soon, even human beings.
We oppose this patriarchal, industrial, commercial and racist domination over life.
10. In our work of bearing and raising children, caring for the sick or disabled, growing, preserving, and preparing food, materials for clothes, and other basic human needs, we women have developed and passed on for generations a wealth of knowledge and skills about dealing with all of nature in a compassionate, humane, ecologically sustainable way. We realize that this knowledge and these skills, as well as the contributions of women to the arts, crafts, culture and social relations are generally not recognized as having value in mainstream science, philosophy, or technology. But these have been and still are vital for the survival of human beings and all of nature. They are valuable human achievements and resources. We want to renew, reaffirm and build upon this female tradition.
11. We strongly believe that reproductive and genetic engineering cannot meet the needs of women or enhance their status in today's societies. We therefore demand the participation and recognition of women in all spheres of life. We want women to have access to resources, income, employment, social security, and a safe environment at work and at home. Quite fundamentally, we demand living and working conditions that assure a life of human dignity for all women worldwide.
12. We demand access for girls to practical knowledge, resources, and skills that are in women's best interest and further women's well being. These include an education about taking care of primary health needs including nutrition. This will empower women and increase women's general health, reduce mortality of women and children. Such primary health care will reduce the number of children born with mental and physical disabilities and also reduce infertility.
13. We demand knowledge and access to safe contraception which does not harm women's bodies. We reject any coercion, be it through force, incentives in the name of population control policies, such as enforced sterilization particularly in camps and in target oriented policies. We demand a stop to the use of dangerous IUDs, unsafe injectables, hormonal implants, such as Norplant, and other hormonal contraceptives as well as anti-fertility vaccines.
14. We support the recovery by women of knowledge, skill and power that gives childbirth, fertility and all women's health care back into the hands of women. We demand recognition, support and facilitation of the work of midwives and re-establishment of midwifery services under the control of women.
15. We demand Iiterature be distributed and education be given about adverse effects of all contraceptive methods.
16. We demand contraceptives for men be developed and that men also be made responsible for contraception.
17. We demand the United Nations and the governments of the respective countries stop population control policies as preconditions for developmental aid.
18. We support the exclusive rights of all women to decide whether or not to bear children without coercion from any man, medical practitioner, government or religion. We demand that women shall not be criminalized for choosing and performing abortion.
19. We oppose the medicalisation and commercialization of the desire of women for motherhood.
20. Internationally, we demand that conditions be created under which social parenthood in a variety of forms meets the needs of children and people who wish to care for children. In particular maternity and child care should be a social concern rather than the responsibility of individual women.
21. We condemn men and their institutions that inflict infertility on women by violence, forced sterilisation, medical maltreatment and industrial pollution and repeal the damage through violent 'repair' technologies.
22. Given the continuing deterioration of women's lives through the application of patriarchal science and technology, we call for an international public trial on medical crimes against women to be organized by women.
23. We demand research into the prevention of infertility as well as an end to the stigmatisation of the infertile. Infertility needs to be acknowledged as a social condition and not as a disease.
24. We protest the use of in vitro fertilization in countries that wish to increase or decrease births. It is a dangerous dehumanizing technology. It uses women as living test sites and producers of eggs and embryos as raw material to enable scientists to work towards further control over the production and quality control of human beings and international business to accumulate profit. Furthermore, it is a failed technology which also takes away resources from basic reproductive health needs.
25. The social discrimination against women is aggravated through the technologies of sex determination and sex pre-selection resulting in a growing adverse sex ratio in some countries. We demand a ban on such applications of these technologies.
26. We are against any kind of bias and discrimination against disabled people including that of genetic screening and counselling. We particularly oppose the human genome project within this context. Prenatal diagnosis, genetic screening and genetic counselling do not offer the solution for disability. Instead we demand the elimination of hazardous drugs radiation, hazardous chemicals at the workplace and in the environment and a solution to the problems of malnutrition and preventable infectious diseases.
27. Disabled people must be integrated into society and accorded full respect as human beings. The responsibility for caring for the disabled must be of social rather than of individual concern.
28. We condemn any national and international traffic in women, eggs and embryos, human organs, body parts, cells or DNA (genetic substance) especially for purposes of reproductive prostitution which exploit women as human incubators, in particular poor women and women in poor countries. We also strongly protest against the existence of 'baby farms' and commercial adoption and surrogacy agencies.
29. We oppose the deliberate release of genetically manipulated organisms worldwide because of its unpredictable and irreversible effects on our environment and health. We also consider the use of genetic engineering in laboratories and factories (biotechnology) to be tantamount to deliberate release, because genetically manipulated organisms can be released accidentally.
30. Deliberate release of genetically manipulated organisms and safety standards in factories and research institutions are of international concern and cannot be decided by certain governments only. The impossibility of democratic control of genetic engineering on a national and international level leads us to reject all forms of genetic engineering.
31. We strictly reject any laws which allow patenting of life forms and processes utilising life forms.
32. We condemn the use or poor countries as test-sites for genetically engineered organisms or other products of genetic engineering such as the bovine growth hormone, rabies vaccine, etc.
33. We fear that the development and application of gene technology in agriculture will repeat and aggravate the damage done by the green revolution; in particular that it will increase the economic dependency of poor countries on rich countries and concentrate power in the hands of a few, both nationally and internationally.
34. We demand an end to technologies and policies which result in natural food being converted into more expensive unnatural food.
35. We oppose the criminalisation and repression of women who are critical of genetic engineering and reproductive technologies or who are against the dehumanizing technologies.
36. We want appropriate technologies that do not violate human dignity and relations. We want them to be reversible, that is to be error friendly, and contribute to preserving biological, cultural and social diversity of all living beings. The technologies must be suited to collective decision-making and democratic participation and control.
37. We women gathered here are natural and social scientists, doctors, lawyers, health activists, journalists, demographers, development workers, community organizers, teachers, social workers, academics, who have been involved actively in issues related to women, health, human rights, education, responsible science, technology and agriculture with a women-oriented perspective in both professional and political work. Having shared our experiences, insights, knowledge, we reaffirm our deep commitment to continue and intensify our work towards humane and just world for all. We will continue this work, despite the numerous restraints and increasing repression, both political and professional, which we face.
38. We appeal to all women and men to unite globally against dehumanising technologies and express our solidarity with all those who seek to uphold and preserve the diversity of life on our planet and the integrity and dignity of all women.
In March 1989, an International Conference on Reproductive and Genetic Engineering and Women’s Reproductive Health was held in Comilla, Bangladesh. This conference was organized by tile Feminist International Network of Resistance to Reproductive and Genetic Engineering (FINRRAGE) and Policy Research for Development Alternatives (UBINIG).
This was the first time that such an international conference was held in a third world country, so as to enable participants to better understand the situation of poverty and the many forms of economic and social oppression faced by people in the third world.
Primarily the conference focused on issues of population control, reproductive technologies and genetic engineering which affect women both in developed and developing countries.
In the course of the 8 day conference, plenary, panel and workshop discussions presented a wealth of information from, a feminist perspective and led to the following statements and demands in the form of the Declaration of Comilla.